Sunday, February 24, 2013

the "metabolic advantage" everybody has looked for?

...Well, except for the CICO-apologists.  ;-)

One of my link-following adventures led me to THIS paper, which led to THIS magazine article, which i can't read in its entirety for less than thirty bucks....  :-P  Aw well, such is life.  The abstract probably says the important stuff.  (It's got enough acronyms in it -- Kindke might find it worth interpreting for me if he gets bored sometime!)

Bile acids induce energy expenditure by promoting intracellular thyroid hormone activation.
Watanabe M, Houten SM, Mataki C, Christoffolete MA, Kim BW, Sato H, Messaddeq N, Harney JW, Ezaki O, Kodama T, Schoonjans K, Bianco AC, Auwerx J.
Source
Institut de Génétique et Biologie Moléculaire et Cellulaire, CNRS/INSERM/ULP, 1 Rue Laurent Fries, 67404 Illkirch, France.
Abstract
While bile acids (BAs) have long been known to be essential in dietary lipid absorption and cholesterol catabolism, in recent years an important role for BAs as signalling molecules has emerged. ...  Here we show that the administration of BAs to mice increases energy expenditure in brown adipose tissue, preventing obesity and resistance to insulin. This novel metabolic effect of BAs is critically dependent on induction of the cyclic-AMP-dependent thyroid hormone activating enzyme type 2 iodothyronine deiodinase (D2) because it is lost in D2-/- mice. Treatment of brown adipocytes and human skeletal myocytes with BA increases D2 activity and oxygen consumption.  ...  In both rodents and humans, the most thermogenically important tissues are specifically targeted by this mechanism because they coexpress D2 and TGR5. The BA-TGR5-cAMP-D2 signalling pathway is therefore a crucial mechanism for fine-tuning energy homeostasis that can be targeted to improve metabolic control.

It looks to me as though this may be the secret of the success of Dr. Donaldson's fatty-meat diet, and possibly the Shangri-La (oil-bibbing branch) as well -- it's all about fats which prompt a squirt of bile for our bodies to process.  I was "promised" a boost from coconut oil which i never observed to benefit me (although i love the stuff and intend to keep using it generously); this could be the big secret.  Coconut oil doesn't require bile for digestion.

It turns out, then, that the fat IN THE MEAT of the Strong Medicine regimen is the trick -- and modern science tells us why.  Donaldson clearly stated that dietary fat was important, as he had learned from Vilhjalmur Stefansson (all-lean-meat diet = BAD).  As a matter of fact, his suggestion was that if you choose to eat a leaner kind of meat than his recommendations, you should buy extra SUET and chop/grind it into your choice to make it appropriately balanced.  As an interesting aside, he observed that most of his patients adapted to a fat-burning metabolism in about five days.  Also, his only recommended exercise (except for special stretching for certain conditions) was a daily half-hour walk.

So forget the low-fat diet (as if we haven't already)!  Put the coconut oil on the back burner!  We've already forgotten heavy exercise and calorie-counting.  To lose fat weight and increase our energy, what we need is enough fuel to convince our bodies they can afford to rev up a bit ... and the best fuel of all is good old-fashioned animal fat.

Sure sounds like a LCHF metabolic advantage to me.

Friday, February 22, 2013

thyroid sufferers -- do NOT be afraid of low-carbing!

I just read the study Eddie linked on The Low Carb Diabetic, about "shifting the paradigm" in treating various illnesses with a low-carb diet (co-authored by our good Adele Hite); i was COMPLETELY on board with the paper till i found THIS statement (emphasis mine):
 There are, however, certain populations in which reducing carbohydrate intake to very low levels may not be appropriate:  patients with ... thyroid defects, .... 
 There are a couple of rationales for why this hypothesis persists, and i wish to gawd somebody would run a proper RCT to straighten it out -- because i'm absolutely, positively sure that the position is BULLSHIT.

I'm not the only one, either.  One of those who agree, Sam the "worldly monk," wrote an outstanding article about this misconception -- i can hardly add anything to make the point better!  It's just that compared to a lot of theorizers, i'm the one in the trenches with considerable experience.  Notably, the only significant argument Sam got was NOT from a hypothyroid....

The more starch/sugar one consumes, the more thyroid hormone is needed by the body to clear the ensuing glucose spike from the blood.  We see the same situation with vitamin C -- the more BG, the more C is needed.  Apparently, lab-test-junkies of the gym-rat persuasion have extrapolated LOW T3 FROM A LOW-CARB DIET!!! without actually experiencing any hypothyroid symptoms ... the absence of which defines a diagnosis of EUthyroidism.

Wooo also CLEARLY elucidated the situation of hypothyroid symptoms being seen in euthyroid individuals who are losing fat weight; it's all about the body getting enough fuel so that it knows it can afford to "waste" energy for optional purposes!  One apparently just does not see people damaging their thyroids irrevocably on a low-carb diet, and becoming clinically hypothyroid!  But you DO see people doing that who insist on eating things like wheat and legumes and sugar and industrial seed-oils -- THAT is where the modern glut of thyroid patients are coming from (opinion:  don't ask me for references).

So if you're hypothyroid and want to try LC-paleo to see if you can improve your health and sense of well-being, DON'T AUTOMATICALLY BELIEVE that because someone as savvy as Adele wrote it, it has to be true.  The paper quoted above makes the point ITSELF, that the historical record of health and dietary recommendations are full of mistakes.  You'll only KNOW if LC gives you a better quality of life if you dive in and try it yourself -- and NOT like that Oz yoyo did for ONE DAY!!!

Thursday, February 21, 2013

pointing fingers at the wrong villains

How synchronicitous!  I just read the year-old WAPF article on salt which ties in very neatly to my recent ponderings on the subject.

We're accustomed to seeing high-carb rodent diets being described as "high-fat" and all their ill effects being blamed on the lard in them -- as though that were good old-fashioned pig-fat from pastured swine instead of the high-PUFA, partially-hydrogenated garbage the passes for lard today.  But i'm not sure the bloated PMSing women out there (of which i was one) might have any clue that it's NOT the salt that came on their pizza or fries that is making them miserable....

Ya know what else causes water retention?  Sugar (and other carbs, especially lactose and fructose if you're intolerant).  Insulin.  Cortisol.  Allergies.  MSG.  Alcohol.  And probably a whole lot of other things, too.  But of course i keep coming back to the fact that "TABLE" SALT takes the rap.

As i pointed out before, i love salt and use it liberally at home.  I NEED salt for the sake of my digestion.  I find it hard to believe that i'm getting significantly more NaCl in restaurants.  When CW slams something that i KNOW is beneficial for me, it makes me mad that others like me (but less headstrong) might believe the idiots and forgo something that would make their health better.  And since the "logical" way CW deals with failure of a public policy is to make the original recommendations stronger, we get stupid reactions like denying school-children the use of salt-shakers....

The WAPF article makes it clear that although in a small population, severe salt restriction may lower BP by single digits, all-cause mortality in the general population seems to rise.  Why is it, with salt and dietary fats, tiny fragments of demographics getting bad results get extrapolated to the rest of us, and now that we have large-and-growing bad effects of grains and other carbs, the cautions against them DON'T happen?  If it were only the case of lobbying, i'd think the egg, dairy and meat-producers would band together and stand as strong as the wheat/corn/soy group does, but it doesn't seem to work that way.

Tuesday, February 19, 2013

what is it about restaurant food?!

It's not like i don't use salt at home -- i LOVE salt.  When i tried the Strong Medicine regimen the first time, i HAD to add salt (Donaldson proscribes it) because my stomach was screwed-up without the chloride.

Most of the time, restaurant food tastes about right, though on rare occasions it's too salty for me.  So WHY does restaurant food cause more water-retention than home-cooked?  Are other sodium products (such as one finds in processed meats) present in ground beef from their suppliers?  I'm not talking about cheap fast-food outlets -- i KNOW there are additives there -- i'm referring to obviously-hand-formed fresh ground beef in my favorite pubs and dives.

???!

Vegetables, too.  We ate out on Friday (Scottish Arms), and mashed turnips came with my pork cheek -- YUM.  Then i introduced my husband to salsify on his second evening back home.  Sunday lunch out with our dear neighbors at Hamburger Mary's -- i was "good" and with my bunless Proud Mary burger i had the seasonal vegetables as a side-dish.  I got around the meat, and ate a cross section of the fresh-veg mixture (peppers and broccoli -- a third to a half of the serving).  The root vegetables didn't seem to do the damage the above-ground crops did -- yesterday i felt the bloat.

Not only are some of us not designed to eat an animal-free diet, but i'm beginning to think that some of us aren't designed to eat many vegetable substances at all.  Again, Donaldson's admonition to avoid "green" vegetables and to favor "yellow" ones hit the mark.  The roots/tubers wear their toxins on the surface, and if you get past that you seem to be home free, but those that flaunt their leaves and flowers for all to reach are toxic (to me at least) through and through.

An update on the subject of cashews....  I had that one bad experience with the cashews that i bought "raw" and soaked and dehydrated last year.  Well, i made a batch of the Fallon/Enig recipe Brazilian Shrimp Stew and got the same response from my digestive system.  It's "cooking" them that does me in -- i can eat them with impunity otherwise!  Fortunately, the almond,coconut and hazelnut flours i make "breads" with don't seem to have the same effect.

I know nuts are dangerously more-ish for me though, and i limit my quantities to a couple of ounces per day.  When i DO have breads, cookies or cakes on hand, i use them sparingly.  A treat is a treat, no matter how low the carb count!

Friday, February 15, 2013

was i "sick" and didn't know it?

Yesterday gave me a return of the old low-energy blues, and after the hypomanic evening i'd had Wednesday, i wondered if i had just overdone my exertions.  I woke up this morning with a stuffy nose, perceptible inflammation, and low-grade headache -- i think i caught somebody's bug, and it was so mild i didn't perceive significant malaise!

Being the reclusive cat-lady* i am, i don't come in contact with a lot of "germs" from day to day.  In the past this has meant that whenever i visit my grandchildren i run the risk of catching all those buggies that are so communicable in the "real world."  I think there's a darned good chance i'm improving my immune system a huge amount at the same time i'm fine-tuning my nutrition.

Not surprising.  If i wasn't getting enough pre-formed vitamin A before to keep my mitrochondria churning out the ATP decently, i probably wasn't getting enough to keep my immune system firing on all eight, either.  We all know that A is important for immunity, and i THOUGHT i was getting enough with my cod-liver oil, but the food version of liver is so much more effective, i won't be buying the Carlson brand of CLO anymore -- i have to doubt its potency.

But today i'm back wanting to trot up the stairs instead of trudge.  I had a couple of ibuprofen and a couple of benedryl, so the aches are almost gone, even though i can still feel a little inflammation in the tissues of my upper respiratory system.  I'm going to get myself a zinc lozenge next time i'm in the bathroom, and use the neti-pot later, and i expect tomorrow will be even better than today.

YIPPEE!  I may have been "sick" but i'm not SIIIIIICK!

______
*  i'm less of a cat-person than a dog-person but ... the leap from dog-lady to BITCH is just too easy!

Thursday, February 14, 2013

most people probably aren't happy today

Last year i wrote about the dark side of Valentines' Day, and i'm not likely to change my mind much about the unfortunate character of this "holiday."  I imagine that others who feel like i do have described their objections well enough, so anything i could write in that direction would be redundant.

One of my objections to the observation of St. Valentine's feast-day as a romantic celebration is ... the time of year!  It must be granted, the "church" which gave us the holiday in the first place has always been AGAINST earthly love, save as it might be a means of procreation = more church MEMBERS = more power = more income.  "The church" is scared to death of sex because it's such a powerful thing, and they've wrapped all sorts of myths around it, like "original sin."  Kiddies, "original sin" is your own bad karma you brought into this life with you, from the last -- it doesn't have a bloody damned thing to do with the fact that we all are "conceived in sin"!  The misogynist "saint" Paul and the raging pedophile Augustine are largely responsible for the ridiculously anti-feminine slant of Christianity and all its writings.

In the middle ages, this feast day (thought to be a cleaned-up version of Rome's Lupercalia) became associated with the convention of "courtly love."  If you're a history buff, you know that it was rare for anyone of wealth or importance to wed a person they were in love with -- marriages were mergers or alliances, and some really inappropriate matches have been made through the centuries with those "ideals" as a guide.  "Courtly love" was all about sleeping with somebody you actually WANTED, although it was dressed up in prettier finery than that.

But from an esoteric point of view, could one possibly choose a WORSE astrological signature for a holiday meant to celebrate affection, romance, and devotion?  I can't see it!  The sun is currently in Aquarius:  the "intellectual" sign; the 50-years-ahead-of-everyone-else sign; the cool-headed, reasonable, detached sign.  Piss-poor time for romance, to me!  And since the inner planets (Mercury=mental, Venus=hedonistic) signs can never be far from the sun, there's a darned good chance they'll never be in an auspicious sign, either.  This year, the moon (emotions) is in Aries (hot-headed, stubborn, selfish, rash), Mercury is in Pisces (a wild-card), Venus in Aquarius, Mars ("drive") is in Pisces also, and Jupiter (good fortune) in Gemini (duality).  Frankly, i don't think it looks good.

If we MUST have a holiday "for lovers" i would lobby for May as a much better time than February.  The first three weeks, the sun is in Taurus, the sign associated with hedonism (also fertility).  Or July, September or October, for various reasons.  Even March!  Give people a CHANCE to have something to celebrate!

[sigh]  Since we're stuck with what we've got, the least we can do is try to make sure our honeys know we CARE.  Be extra nice today, because most people need it!

Wednesday, February 13, 2013

... and liver led to vitamin-A reading

My energy has been SO phenomenally better recently, well ... i just HAD to look at this gift-horse's teeth! :-D  I googled "vitamin a and energy" and hit the jackpot.

I read (in an blog that doesn't deserve quoting because it won't let me copy a single PHRASE to paste here) that in the FASEB Journal there was an article about retinol's role in ATP production.  AHA!  Then a short paddle around the PubMed pool revealed another wealth of information -- the author has done a LOT of work on mitochondria, our favorite organelle!  ...Okay, okay -- they're ALL important....

It's going to take awhile to read and digest this information, but the starting-point is here:  http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/19812372 and the takeaway is this -- low retinol results in bare-minimal energy.

I also googled the factoid that 45% of people don't convert carotenes to retino's adequately; all in one place i got the (uncited) number i was looking for, PLUS material for thought.
Some people may not absorb adequate carotenes from the diet due to digestive problems and some people, even those with adequate thyroid activity, seem to have some difficulty converting the carotenes to the active form of vitamin A.  In one study, up to 47% of British women were unable to adequately convert beta-carotene to vitamin A.  The problem may be even worse in some populations.*
Am i the only one who goes on point (the hunter-bitch that i am) at the notion that SOME PEOPLE ARE JUST NOT DESIGNED TO LIVE ON AN ANIMAL-FREE DIET?  Some people do not convert this ABSOLUTELY ESSENTIAL nutrient from the form in which it's offered in the modern diet!  Every time i see the title "foods that provide vitamin A" followed by a list of friggin' VEGETABLES (which have NO retinol content) i want to erupt.

But no time to read today!  I'm teaching a class in tatting to a couple of dozen ladies at the Chatillon-de Menil House tonight, and i still need to print my hand-outs and collect my examples.  :-)  Later!!!

________
 *  see, i LOVE to give credit where it's due!  it's the writers who are so friggin' scared that somebody's gonna STEEEEEAL their work that they make it really difficult to quote them AT ALL....  oh well -- this quote is from www.drlwilson.com/ARTICLES/VITAMIN%20A.htm